|
Just How Stupid Are We?: Facing the Truth About the American Voter | 
 enlarge | Author: Rick Shenkman
Publisher: Basic Books
Category: Book
List Price: $25.00
Buy Used: $9.99
You Save: $15.01 (60%)
New (42) Used (24) Collectible (1) from $9.99
Rating:  45 reviews
Sales Rank: 28980
Media: Hardcover
Pages: 224
Number Of Items: 1
Shipping Weight (lbs): 0.7
Dimensions (in): 8.3 x 5.6 x 0.9
ISBN: 0465077714
Dewey Decimal Number: 320.973
EAN: 9780465077717
ASIN: 0465077714
Publication Date: June 9, 2008
Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days
| |
| Also Available In:
|
| Similar Items:
|
| Editorial Reviews:
Product Description
Politicians tell us constantly that they trust the wisdom of "The American People." New York Times best-selling author Rick Shenkman explains why we shouldn't--at least when it comes to politics. Levees break in New Orleans. Iraq descends into chaos. The housing market teeters on the brink of collapse. Americans of all political stripes are heading into the 2008 election with the sense that something has gone terribly wrong with American politics. But what exactly? Democrats blame Republicans and Republicans blame Democrats. Greedy corporate executives, rogue journalists, faulty voting machines, irresponsible defense contractors--we blame them, too. The only thing everyone seems to agree on, in fact, is that the American people are entirely blameless. In Just How Stupid Are We?, best-selling historian and renowned myth-buster Rick Shenkman takes aim at our great national piety: the wisdom of the American people. The hard truth is that American democracy is more direct than ever--but voters are misusing, abusing, and abdicating their political power. Americans are paying less and less attention to politics at a time when they need to pay much more: Television has dumbed politics down to the basest possible level, while the real workings of politics have become vastly more complicated. Shenkman offers concrete proposals for reforming our institutions--the government, the media, civic organizations, political parties--to make them work better for the American people. But first, Shenkman argues, we must reform ourselves.
|
| Customer Reviews: Read 40 more reviews...
 The dumbing of the American electorate June 12, 2008
Kerry Walters (Lewisburg, PA USA)
118 out of 127 found this review helpful
Many of us probably have suspected for a long time that our soundbit, infotainmented, and MTVed and Gameboyed culture is eroding our critical skills. As individuals, many of us simply may not care too much. After all, a man's entertainment center is his castle. But as citizens of a democracy, we ought to be concerned. As John Stuart Mill said in the 19th century, the democratic premise rests on the presence of an educated citizenry. Ideas and policies can neither be examined nor tested in the marketplace in the absence of an informed and critical public.
Rick Shenkman's Just How Stupid Are We? not only wholeheartedly embraces Mill's observation, but also eliminates any remaining doubt about the growing inadequacy of the American electorate to participate responsibly in democracy. A few of the chilling facts with which the book is crammed:
--half of us can name 4 characters from "The Simpsons," but less than a quarter can name more than one of the guaranteed rights in the First Amendment.
--only 2 out of 5 voters can name all three branches of the federal government.
--only 1 in 5 know that there are 100 federal senators.
--only 1 in 7 can find Iraq on a map.
--only one-fifth of Americans between ages 18-34 bother to keep up with current events.
How to account for this frightening state of ignorance? And just as importantly, what to do about it?
In answer to the first question, Shenkman suggests that the steady erosion of party and labor bosses, who despite their frequent misuse of power at least tended to keep their followers politically informed, has thrown the average voter to the mercy of shallow network commentary (if that) and corporate manipulation. Moreover, the two main political parties have in their respective ways encouraged the dumbing-down trend. Until recently, conservatives never took populism seriously anyway, and so didn't care how ill-educated citizens were. Progressives, on the other hand, embraced an almost mystical faith in the wisdom of the common man. The upshot, says Shenkman, is that we're now "in the pitiful position [where] neither liberals nor conservatives are prepared to say to The People: stop and pay attention. Liberals cannot because their ideology leaves them unprepared to find fault with The People. Conservatives have not because The People repeatedly put them in power."
Bleak as the present crisis of political literacy is, Shenkman doesn't think that the decline is unstoppable. Some of the ideas for reform he floats include a restoration of electoral college autonomy, a return to state legislatures' selecting federal senators, and successful completion of a civics exam as a prerequisite for voting. These and similar policies, he only partly whimsically says, could be bound up in the passage of a "Too Many Stupid Voters Act."
Shenkman's book is reader-friendly, insightful in places, and provocative throughout. But it may suffer from the same myopia that afflicted John Stuart Mill and others of his ilk: the conviction that all we need to get people involved more responsibly in democracy is education. Americans today have more formal schooling than they ever did. Although we may be a shallow culture, we're probably not stupid. So if more and more of us are turning off from politics and refusing to make ourselves informed about current events, perhaps what's going on is an act of the will rather than a laziness of the mind--apathy born of mistrust or despair rather than sheer illiteracy. If that's the case even in part, more education certainly wouldn't hurt. But it won't solve our current malaise.
Did we deserve Bush? June 15, 2008
Julie Neal (Sanibel Island, Fla.)
46 out of 55 found this review helpful
This intriguing book has as its premise that George W. Bush was a terrible president. But the American people voted him into office at least once. That begs the question: Did we deserve him? Are we complicit in his failures? Have the American people turned into dunces?
I couldn't put this book down. Its exploration into sloganeering, conspiracy theories, myth-making, image-driven television news and so much more was fascinating. It made me think.
Another book that touches on this subject is The Assault on Reason by Al Gore. One of his points is that a cause of the decline of reasoned political thought is television. Gore contends that when more Americans started getting their news from TV instead of newspapers, the emphasis changed from reading, an activity that by its nature activates the parts of the brain involved with reasoning, to watching, which elicits emotion but not thought. In Just How Stupid Are We? author Shenkman makes the same point. "The advantage of television is that the viewer can feel and experience politics. But as a transmission belt of information it is far inferior to newspapers. The American people don't hear what you are saying if the pictures are saying something different."
Personally, I believe the American people were not so much stupid as apathetic during the Bush years. When you feel you don't have a voice, you stop talking and turn away.
Here's the chapter list:
1. The Problem
2. Gross Ignorance
3. Are the Voters Irrational?
4. The Importance of Myths
5. Giving Control to the People
6. The Power of Television
7. Our Dumb Politics: The Big Picture
8. Our Mindless Debate About 9/11
9. We Can't Even Talk About How Stupid We Are
Coda: Hope
Ignorance Is Not Bliss June 23, 2008
Retired Reader (Maryland)
33 out of 35 found this review helpful
The "Sage of Baltimore", H.L. Menken, an early 20th Century newspaper man and social critic, once observed that nobody ever went broke by underestimating the taste of the American people. The theme of this book might well be that no politician ever lost an election by underestimating the ignorance of the American voter. In spite of its title this book actually does not argue that the American Voter is stupid. Rather Shenkman contends that the American People are ignorant especially of basic geography and history. Further he argues that they suffer from a terminal attention deficit syndrome. Together these shortcomings routinely prevent the American Public from being able to understand complex thoughts and issues that cannot be reduced to thirty second sound bits. As the book makes clear this is exacerbated by the modern phenomenon of public polling and then treating the results as actual news. As any rational examination demonstrates, most polls are virtually meaningless and even if well conducted the average poll respondent is incapable of understanding or indifferent to what is really being asked. These are harsh judgments, but Shenkman supports them with a good deal antidotal evidence. And he is not alone in his conclusion that the American People may lack the sagacity so often attributed to them by politicians seeking their votes. Any serious reading of the Federalist Papers or indeed the U.S. Constitution will reveal that far from having a faith in the abiding wisdom of the people our founding fathers considered them inflammatory dolts and tried to limit their influence in government. This book suggests that they may have been correct.
 Entertaining, but raises more questions than it answers July 12, 2008
Brandon Wilkening (Bloomington, IN United States)
31 out of 32 found this review helpful
I should state at the outset that I agree with the author's core thesis. I think he's on to something when he argues that democracy is only as good as the quality and wisdom of "The People" who are by definition the source of legitimacy under democracy. I think he is absolutely correct that we too often focus our discussion of what ails us on the rotten politicians, the misleading media, and other nefarious forces that are out to bamboozle the voters. While these other factors certainly do merit criticism, Shenkman correctly contends that The People lose the right to complain about the state of their political system when they refuse to follow the news and stay informed on the issues.
Nevertheless, beyond agreeing with this essential point, I didn't find this book as compelling as I thought I would. Basically this short book amounts to a sort of jeremiad against our citizens' lack of political knowledge. It reads quite fast, as I got through it in a few hours, but I didn't feel it brought anything new to the table.
My main problem is that, while Shenkman does succeed in providing further evidence that, yes, Americans aren't terribly bright when it comes to politics, history, and foreign affairs, he doesn't seem to engage in a sustained analysis of WHY. He provides some evidence that the problem has become worse over time. Why? I wish he would have undertaken a more thorough analysis of the educational system. He hardly talks about the internet, except in the last chapter, where he briefly states he believes it holds promise to elevate political discourse (which actually flies in the face of some recent analyses). He reserves most of his criticism for television, to which he devotes a full chapter. I largely agree with his analysis of television, but even here, his critique is incomplete. He places most of the blame on the fact that through television politics has become more superficial and devoid of substance; he hardly talks at all about the fact that the entertainment industry spawned by television provides innumerable distractions from politics and social issues.
I thought the most fascinating part of the book was his historical analysis of the main parties' attitudes towards the masses. He points out that the founding fathers, as well as early 20th century conservatives, were profoundly skeptical regarding the ability of the citizens to make informed decisions. It was only after Republicans started winning at the ballot that they become the anti-elitist party of the common folks.
My main problem with his lack of diagnosis is that he doesn't provide a very clear path for where to go from here. Yes, he does offer some prescriptions for how to heal our body politic in the last chapter, but his proposals seem like an afterthought. There are the usual suggestions to revamp civics education in high school and college. But his main idea for how to reconnect the electorate to the Democratic Party? They must reinvigorate labor unions! Yes, that should solve the problem!
Basically, my main disappointment with the book lies with the fact that Shenkman really is on to something, as he hints at a rarely discussed problem at the core of our society. But in failing to vigorously analyze WHY Americans have become so woefully uninformed about and disengaged from politics, he can't really offer any viable solutions for how to fix the problem.
Shenkman is an Optimist! June 15, 2008
Loyd E. Eskildson (Phoenix, AZ.)
18 out of 19 found this review helpful
Both sides blame the other for America's current problems, and the American people seem blameless. Shenkman, however, takes aim at "the wisdom of the American people" that we so often hear referred. TV has dumbed politics down to the lowest possible level (emphasis on appearance, vs. substance; emphasis on emotional appeals), while reality has become vastly more complicated. (Anyone believe the "issues of the day" in Colonial times were as complex as today?)
Democracy is rooted in the assumption that we are knowledgeable and rational - instead we are hard-wired to myths (eg. 9/11 was punishment for gays, etc., Saddam was behind Bin Laden, they dislike us for our democracy), and know less than necessary for informed decision making. Yet, over the past four decades American politics has put more and more power directly into the hands of ordinary voters through polls (even as they are manipulated to create the illusion of accuracy), initiatives, and primaries. Ignorance, disinclination to seek reliable sources of information, short-sightedness, and susceptibility to meaningless phrases, stereotypes, and simplistic assertions are more rampant than ever. As evidence, Shenkman points out that presidential speech levels have dropped from the 12th-grade level to the 7th, fewer can state what the political parties stand for, and fewer read newspapers regularly.
Shenkman also believes that our elites have failed us as well - using emotional words (eg. "freedom," "liberty"), and promulgating half-truths (if even that).
"Our democracy is only 200 years old - what makes us think it is permanent?" (Arthur Schlesinger) In less than ten years America has lost millions of jobs with good wages, health care and pension benefits, while piling up trillions in debt for ruinous war and trade policies. At the same time our education and health care systems outpace all others in spending, while lagging in results, and our environment is seriously threatened on several fronts.
Shenkman believes these problems can be cured through eg. mandating civics classes in college. Not likely - becoming an informed, objective citizen is too demanding, requiring extensive knowledge of facts, as well as statistical analysis and the design of experiments.
|
|
|
|
| |
